8 kitchen items not worth spending money on – 'the best renovations maximize value, not cost'

A kitchen renovation is one of the most expensive investments you’ll make in your home, and while it’s tempting to include every luxury, interior designers agree that many high-end features are simply not worth the hefty price tag.

The secret to a successful kitchen remodel is knowing where to splurge (such as high-quality kitchen cabinet ideas and durable kitchen countertops) and where to save.

The kitchen splurges to avoid

Here are eight items that professionals say you should skip, using that money instead on elements that truly enhance function and longevity.

1. Pot fillers (and downdraft vents)

A pot filler – the swing-out faucet over the cooktop – looks luxurious but often leads to maintenance headaches and limited practicality. Interior designer Becky Shea warns, ‘Pot fillers may look stylish and convenient, but they often come with unnecessary costs, both in installation and upkeep. Plus, they don’t solve the issue of having to carry heavy pots back to the sink for draining, so their practicality is often overstated.’

Similarly, built-in downdraft ventilation systems should be avoided, as they are often too weak to effectively pull grease and smoke down and away from the cooktop. Invest in a powerful, properly ducted extractor hood instead. Once meant to be hidden away, the extractor hood has become a major player.

Getting kitchen extraction right is key to a clean, healthy home. A good extractor removes odors, grease, and steam, making the space easier to maintain and more enjoyable to use. Chosen with care, it should complement both your hob and kitchen layout – while bold designs can add flair to the overall aesthetic.

2. Warming drawers

Warming drawers are a classic example of a luxury that often goes underused. Interior designer Becky Shea explains, ‘Warming drawers can feel indulgent, but unless you frequently host large gatherings, they rarely see much use. In most kitchens, they end up occupying valuable space that could be better used for pantry items or bulky cookware.’

In reality, your oven can achieve the same results when set to a low temperature, rendering the drawer largely redundant. While some appliances may seem like convenient additions, it’s worth considering whether you’ll actually use them – or if they’ll just sit idle.

Becky Shea recommends investing in versatile, hardworking kitchen appliances instead. ‘A good oven can handle multiple tasks, making a warming drawer unnecessary unless you consistently need it,’ she says.

3. Built-in coffee makers

The desire for a seamless, integrated kitchen is understandable, but sometimes a striking stand-alone appliance is the smarter choice.

Miami-based interior designer Ania Agárdy warns of the high cost of built-in models: ‘Another temptation difficult to resist is a built-in coffee maker that can set you back a couple of thousand dollars when a chic stand-alone one is just as useful. After all, it’s the quality of the coffee that really matters.’

While hiding appliances behind cabinet doors can make a kitchen feel more streamlined, not every item needs to be built-in – and some simply aren’t worth the premium. There are plenty of good coffee makers that are both stylish and high-performing, so why hide them? For the best balance of form and function, choose models that look good on your countertop and deliver a great cup every time.

The OXO Brew 8-Cup Coffee Maker, available on Amazon, is currently our best-rated non-toxic coffee maker.

4. Over-the-range microwaves

Over-the-range microwaves may save counter space, but they often fall short in functionality. They occupy prime real estate, and their built-in exhaust systems rarely provide adequate ventilation, leaving smoke and cooking odors lingering in your kitchen. A better option is a discreet drawer microwave or a compact countertop model tucked neatly into a cabinet.

5. High-end steam ovens and specialty appliances

Resist the urge to splurge on every new high-tech appliance. Claudia Dorsch, founder of Claudia Interiors, advises: ‘I have a steam oven that I never use. Before purchasing any high-end appliance, ask yourself what features you really need and will use.’ Often, a versatile oven or a popular gadget like an air fryer will see far more use than a single-purpose specialty unit.

Kitchen appliances are investments, so it’s important to choose wisely. As small appliances become increasingly trendy, focus on what truly adds value to your kitchen. Consider gadgets that complement your existing setup – perhaps an air fryer fills a gap, or a stand mixer better suits the way you cook and entertain.

6. Single-purpose gadgets – juicers, slicers, spiralizers

This rule applies to small kitchen gadgets as well. Becky Shea highlights juicers as a common regret: ‘I totally get the appeal of a juicer – it looks sleek, and having one just feels like you’re making a healthy choice. But before you invest, consider whether you’ll truly commit to using it. They can be bulky, take up counter space, and cleaning them can be a chore. More often than not, they end up stored in a cabinet once the initial excitement fades.’

Similarly, gadgets like avocado slicers, onion choppers, or electric can openers are often unnecessary, since a good chef’s knife or a simple manual tool can easily replace them.

On small kitchen appliances, it’s best not to chase every trending gadget – you’ll just end up with cluttered countertops filled with items you rarely touch.

For an exceptional knife, the Shun Classic Paring Knife on Amazon is a top pick – and it’s even a favorite of Meghan Markle.

7. Trendy appliance finishes

Don’t replace functional appliances just to follow a trend. Designer Claudia Dorsch recommends a mix-and-match approach: ‘Focus on investing in the one or two items that matter most to you.’

For everything else, stick to timeless finishes. Steer clear of fads like black stainless steel, which scratches easily and cannot be repaired, and remember that fully exposed stainless steel can be difficult to keep spotless.

To create a cohesive look, the smartest move is often to integrate less visible appliances, such as dishwashers and refrigerators, with matching cabinet panels.

8. Touchless faucets

Though touchless faucets are convenient for hygiene, they come with a high price tag and potential maintenance headaches. Their sensors can be finicky, and installation often requires specialized plumbing. Instead, consider investing in a high-quality, commercial-style pull-down faucet with a strong warranty.

These faucets provide reliable performance, easy maintenance, and versatile functionality. Look for models with durable finishes, smooth spray options, and a flexible hose – features that make everyday tasks easier without the technological complications of touchless systems.

A successful kitchen renovation is about maximizing value, not simply maximizing cost. By prioritizing high-quality core components – such as cabinets, dependable countertops, and a great range – over these easily regretted luxuries, you ensure your money is spent on function and timeless style that will last for decades.